I'm really torn and could use some advice. My 16-year-old poodle, Max, has always been a strong little dude, but recently he's been diagnosed with a severe leg issue. Our vet mentioned that amputation could potentially give him more mobility and ease some of his pain, but with his age, I worry about putting him through such a major procedure. On the other hand, there's the option of comfort care to manage his pain and let him live out his days peacefully. I'm heartbroken and don't know what the best decision is for him. We're in Michigan, and sometimes I wonder if the cold makes his leg hurt even more. I just want to do what's right for my boy. Has anyone gone through something similar with an older pet? How do you decide between these options? Any advice or personal experiences would really help. Thanks so much.
Hello there! Thank you for reaching out with your concern. It’s clear you’re doing your best for your poodle at such a delicate time in their life.
First, let’s look at why amputation might be considered. In older dogs, it’s often related to severe injury, cancer, or chronic pain that drastically affects their quality of life. In some cases, amputation can relieve pain and improve mobility if the dog is otherwise healthy and has a strong quality of life. However, surgery in a senior pet, especially at 16 years, carries higher risks due to anesthesia and slower recovery times.
Comfort care is an equally valid option. This involves managing pain with medication, providing supportive care like soft bedding, and ensuring their environment is easy to navigate. Think about adding ramps or cushioning any slippery floors to prevent falls. Monitor closely for signs of worsening pain such as whining, limping, decreased appetite, or not wanting to move.
If your poodle shows signs of declining quality of life — difficulty breathing, persistent pain, or has trouble moving around — those are important signals that need attention.
Ultimately, this is a personal decision, and both choices are committed to your poodle’s wellbeing. I recommend booking a video consult with Dial A Vet so we can discuss your options in detail and see what will best support your furry friend during this time.
The "Ask a Vet" forum on Dial A Vet offers general information and helpful tips on pet health, but it's
not a substitute for professional veterinary care. The advice here doesn't create a veterinarian-client-patient relationship, and our vets can't diagnose or treat your pet remotely.
For emergencies or specific medical concerns, always contact your local veterinarian immediately. Your pet's health is unique, and decisions should only be made after consulting with a qualified professional. By using this forum, you acknowledge these limitations and agree to seek in-person veterinary advice for all your pet's health needs. View our
content guidelines.